I am comparing Pia Toscado and James Durbin. After looking through some websites it seems like those are the top two favorites to win American Idol. First Pia she’s a little shyer, she’s not super shy but she’s not super outgoing. Her vocals can reach to the heavens and back. :0. Her type of music is more moderate and calm. On the American Idol fan club she has 7,306 where as James has 8,211. James is a more outgoing type of singer, he gets the crowd going. He’s definitely a rocker! Even though has a hard rocker he also has a soft side in his vocals and music. I think he’s liked a lot also because of his story (he has turrets’) and his crazy high vocals. So far Pia is the only person on Idol this season that has gotten a standing ovation from the judges. James is the only person on Idol that had gotten J-Lo to go crazy and dance. All in all both Pia and James both deserve to win, they are both amazing singers. I definitely think it is going to come down to those two. If one of them messes up it could cost them, so far neither of them have messed up on a song that they have sung. If one of them messes up then I think the other one will end up winning. If they both do amazing each week then I think it will be the closest voting American Idol has ever seen! Even if James or Pia don’t win they are both going to get a record deal no matter what.

James Durbin
Image Source Page: http://celebritynewsandstyle.com/more-american-idol-heartbreak-james-durbin-112/
![]() |
Pia Toscado |
Image from: http://www.seat42f.com/american-idol-reveals-remaining-top-24-semifinalists.html
SOURCES:
http://myidol.americanidol.com/go/thread/view/86789/27143961/The_Official_Fan_Club_and_Thread_Listing_for_Pia_Toscano_(The_Sweet_P’s)
http://myidol.americanidol.com/go/thread/view/86789/26991113/***James_Durbin_Fanlist~Durbinators***
http://myidol.americanidol.com/go/thread/view/86789/27142881/***POLL_-_WHO_WILL_WIN_AI10***?pg=1&pg=1